How to Write the Villanova University Supplemental Essays: Examples + Guide 2023/2024

If you have any doubt about what Villanova’s missions are, one of them is right on its home page, front and center: Ignite change.

Let’s break down what that means. First, Villanova doesn’t want just great thinkers or great students on campus; rather, it wants great doers (or, if you will, “igniters”). Second, if any word can describe our world over the last several years, it’s “change.” So it’s probably no surprise that Villanova’s supplements this year (in large part) give you the opportunity to explore how you have and will make change—within yourself, within your larger community, and even globally.

Inciting all this change may seem like a lot of responsibility. Documenting it in these essays may seem even more so. Take a deep breath. In through the nose. Out through the mouth. Better? Good. We’re here to answer your many questions and put your mind at ease.

Want to get a better sense of what Villanova is looking for before you start writing? You’ll find an extensive, by-the-numbers look at its offerings, from enrollment and tuition statistics to student life and financial aid information, on its Common Data Set. For deep insights into how this private research university envisions student success (and how it wants to grow and evolve), read its strategic priorities. Reading through this will give you a strong idea of Villanova’s values.

Because these prompts are new this year, we don’t, unfortunately, have many Villanova-specific samples to share. But what we do have for you are the tips, tricks, and insights that will help you analyze the prompts and create thoughtful responses to them. So let’s dive right in.

What are the Villanova University supplemental essay prompts?

Villanova Supplemental Essay Prompt #1

Please select one of the four essay prompts listed below to fulfill the writing requirement. Please respond in about 250 words.

  1. St. Augustine states that well-being is “not concerned with myself alone, but with my neighbor’s good as well.” How have you advocated for equity and justice in your communities?
  2. As an Augustinian community, we believe that you should see people for who they are. Please share with us a time when you were misjudged based on your identity or background.
  3. In the Villanova community, we believe that we all learn from one another. What is a lesson in life that you have learned that you would want to share with others?
  4. At Villanova, we often say “each of us strengthens all of us.” In a time of personal challenges, how do you borrow from the strength of others?

Villanova Supplemental Essay Prompt #2

Why do you want to call Villanova your new home and become part of our community? Please respond in about 150 words.

How to write each Supplemental Essay Prompt for Villanova

how to write Villanova Supplemental Essay Prompt #1

Please select one of the four essay prompts listed below to fulfill the writing requirement. Please respond in about 250 words.

  1. St. Augustine states that well-being is “not concerned with myself alone, but with my neighbor’s good as well.” How have you advocated for equity and justice in your communities?
  2. What is the truest thing that you know?
  3. One of the themes in St. Augustine's book, Confessions, is the idea of redemption. Tell us your story of being given a second chance.
  4. In the Villanova community, we believe that we all learn from one another. What is a lesson in life that you have learned that you would want to share with others?
  5. Augustine’s “Miracles are not contrary to nature but only contrary to what we know about nature.” Tell us about a societal issue that you believe the wonder of technology is well-poised to help solve.

Let’s take those one at a time.

Option 1: St. Augustine states that well-being is “not concerned with myself alone, but with my neighbor’s good as well.” How have you advocated for equity and justice in your communities?

Villanova expects its students to demonstrate its Augustinian values of Veritas, Unitas, Caritas (Truth, Unity, Love) through both their work toward the common good and their support for one another. This prompt offers you the opportunity to show just how well you walk the walk and talk the talk (and, well, write the essay). How? In four easy(ish) steps:

Step 1: Find your “what” and “why.” Don’t feel like this activism had to have been big. Maybe you organized a Black Lives Matter event in your small conservative town that resulted in a mindset shift among local leaders and law enforcement. But maybe you simply volunteered to register 18-year-olds to vote in front of Town Hall. No less important or impactful. More important than the size of the event is how passionate you are about your topic. So think: What is it that really matters to you? What topic engages your inner problem-solver? Is it gun violence in school? Dress code equality? Vaccine mandates? 

Step 2: Now identify your “who.” You can take a similar small-to-large approach when considering the community you’ve advocated for. Remember: You belong to a number of communities. Family, school, work, teams and clubs, neighborhood, state, global. And you serve unique roles in each. To help you brainstorm this part, here’s a guide that can help you think through the different communities you’re a part of. 

Step 3: It’s time to outline your “how.” What specific actions have you taken—not just to raise awareness about this societal issue, but to also take concrete action toward creating that equity and justice? It could be as simple as a conversation or as big as a foundation you’ve started (or bigger). Villanova wants to see those concrete steps that have transformed you from “thoughtful idealist” to “action-oriented changemaker.”

Step 4: When you go to write, heavy up the details. While the devil may be in the details, the details will help you show your commitment to equity and justice in one or all of the communities you belong to. Tell that richly detailed story about your efforts. Let the admission officer see you’re more than a thinker. You’re someone who takes action—and Villanova is the place to do it. 

Option 2: St. Augustine states that wAs an Augustinian community, we believe that you should see people for who they are. Please share with us a time when you were misjudged based on your identity or background. ell-being is “not concerned with myself alone, but with my neighbor’s good as well.” How have you advocated for equity and justice in your communities?

Take note of a recurring theme in these prompts: they’re focusing on Villanova’s Augustinian roots. As stated on their website, Villanova is the only Augustinian Catholic university in the United States. So if you haven’t already, you might poke around the “Mission and Ministry” part of Villanova’s website to learn a bit about what being an “Augustinian community” means to Villanova.

This prompt is asking for a personal story, a moment in your life when you felt others made quick judgments or assumptions about you based on your identity or background. Note that you can take a fairly broad definition of “identity or background.” Sure, this can be an essay that focuses on a moment related to your ethnicity, socioeconomic status, gender, or religion, but it can also focus on any other facet of your identity.

No matter which aspect of yourself you explore, note that this isn't simply about recalling an incident; it's about reflection. This means that it's crucial to not just describe the event, but to delve into how it made you feel, how it affected your perception of yourself and the world, what you did in response, and what you learned from it (which ideally should have something to do with Augustininian values).

There are a lot of ways you could successfully tackle this prompt. One way could be as a mini narrative essay that makes the following beats:

  1. Describe the moment. Use specific details to put us in that moment where you were “misjudged based on your identity or background.”

  2. How’d you feel / what needs did you have? When you were misjudged, what thoughts went through your mind? What emotions did you feel?

  3. What actions did you take, and what did you learn? The goal here will be to try to connect what you’ve learned to Villanova’s Augustinian values. To be clear, you don’t need to frame being “misjudged” as a good thing. This doesn’t need to be an essay where you say something like “gee, being misjudged wasn’t fun, but thank goodness it helped me learn [insert value]!”

Example:

I toss the ball to second, knowing the precise moment my shortstop, Charlie, will reach the base. I know because we’ve done this together for 10 years. He throws to first, a perfectly executed 4-6-3 double play. 

I love sports. Nothing else gives me the same feeling of connection to my peers as we push our limits. 

But when I leave the field, that connection disappears. While I excel on the field, I’m also a total nerd in the classroom. My teammates define themselves as athletes, and academics make me ‘other.’

When I joined the team, I was targeted for being nerdy and quiet. The worst part was my three best friends of 10 years, including Charlie, laughed loudest. They isolated me, calling me “nerd” or “gay” (homophobia is common among athletes here). I didn’t know how to voice my feelings of pain and betrayal. 

At first, I tried to conceal the other parts of me and play only the athlete role around them. I even tried laughing along with their mockery. But denying my true self only made me feel more alone. I stopped pretending. 

On the field, I became a leader, even being made captain. Off the field, I became a one-man team. I learned to value the varied parts of myself, to define myself instead of letting others do so, but I also know there is someplace, both in and out of the classroom, where I can be accepted as a nerd, athlete, and so much more. (250 words)

— — —

Tips + Analysis

  1. Quickly put us “in” a moment. 250 words isn’t enough space to describe an extended anecdote about your entire history with baseball / theater / volunteering, etc… It is enough space to do what this writer does: quickly and efficiently use details to show the writers a key, context-building experience. Later on in the essay, the author quickly references moments with language like “Charlie laughed loudest.” Note that we don’t get an extended description of the hurtful moments that led to that laughter, but we don’t need them, do we? A sufficient picture is painted for us by the author’s careful use of key details.

  2. Vulnerability & Growth. The heart of this essay delves into the writer’s experience of isolation and pain. Their admission of trying to fit in, even at the cost of denying their true self, is a pretty vulnerable thing to admit. But it's not all about struggling. The subsequent transformation from a silenced team member to a confident captain paints a powerful arc of growth. That transformation was true for this writer, and if it’s true for you, too, great! Feel free to write about it. But know, too, that sometimes, pain is just pain. You don’t need to frame a hurtful experience as ultimately contributing to your growth. Instead, you could explore how those experiences helped you learn about yourself or others.

  3. Concluding with Self-Acceptance. The ending gracefully ties back to the Villanova prompt, emphasizing the importance of seeing people for who they are. The applicant acknowledges the various facets of their identity and expresses a hope to find a space where all those aspects can coexist harmoniously. They don’t explicitly name-drop Villanova as that place here. This is a great example of restraint—if they did say something like “I haven’t found that place yet, but I’m sure it’s Villanova!”, they would have risked making the whole story feel a bit contrived. Instead, by focusing on values, not a specific place, the writer’s  determination to define themselves, rather than being defined by others, leaves a lasting impression.

Option 3: In the Villanova community, we believe that we all learn from one another. What is a lesson in life that you have learned that you would want to share with others?

General tips for addressing this prompt:

  1. Get school-specific. Villanova is showing you the way here. Because school officials explicitly reference the Villanova community, make sure you’ve done your research and cite resources you might like to engage with given the communities you are, or want to be, part of. Check out our “Why us?” guide for more help on connecting your experiences to what you'll bring to Villanova. 

  2. Keep it simple. You might be super jazzed about your topic. That’s great! You definitely want that enthusiasm to shine through. That said, the prompt asks specifically for you to elaborate on a lesson you’ve learned. When you explain what you’ve learned, try to be as succinct as possible. You want your reader to walk away knowing your answer to the question. That will also make it easier for you to think of specific examples to illustrate how you’ve grown from the lesson you’ve learned.

  3. Use active verbs so readers get a clear sense of what you’ve done. This just makes things more engaging and dynamic overall. Check out our epic list of verbs on this blog post for more inspiration. 

Here’s an example we love.

Example:

I ran into a pole in first grade, so my elementary school painted all of their poles bright yellow. I like to think that I made an impact on that school just as much as that pole made an impact on me. Early on, I learned that people’s small actions can be catalysts for significant change that is often larger than themselves.  

By high school, I was more aware of my surroundings and interested in making a different kind of impact. I leapt at the opportunity to spearhead a new Bedford Academy Opportunity trip to Cambodia: Changing the Way the World Views Girls—I was determined to travel with a purpose. Our agenda was packed: we taught English in remote villages, witnessed the effects of sex trafficking, and heard from twelve-year-old abuse survivors. I was not expecting this trip to alter my own perspective on women’s equality as much as it did; I was shocked to realize the extent to which women are discriminated against everywhere. 

I have never forgotten that I have the ability to be a part of the solution, which is why through the Speak Up For the Poor organization, I created a branch to Cambodia advocating for the education of girls in impoverished communities. I would bring the lessons from this work to the Villanova community by connecting with student organizations, such as TedxVillanovaU and Villanova Feminism Society, to provoke discussion on uplifting women through education. 

I truly believe that one person has the capability to make a difference. I want to share my story to encourage others to find something that they are passionate about in order to inspire change. In this way, I can ensure that my impact on Villanova will last longer than yellow paint.

— — —

Tips + Analysis

  1. Don’t discount the small moments. At its core, this question is about demonstrating growth. You don’t have to have had a huge revelation in an epic movie-worthy moment to have learned an important lesson. In this student’s case, he ran into a pole. At first glance, not super impressive. However, the way he describes it humorously and succinctly helps readers see how this small moment of clumsiness drastically impacted his way of approaching the world. Big lessons can come from seemingly insignificant actions, events, or thoughts. Showing that you can find meaning in these moments is impressive and essay-worthy.

  2. Connect to communities. Remember that “community” is the key word here. After his brief introduction about walking into a pole, the author uses his next two paragraphs to elaborate on two specific organizations he’s part of that relate to the lesson he learned from the pole incident. Remember, even though the focus of the question seems to be on the lesson, it’s actually more interested in how the lesson prepared you to do something impactful afterwards. You walked into a pole and learned this abstract lesson about how small actions can catalyze big change ... so what? The bulk of your essay should be spent answering the implicit “so what” of this prompt. 

  3. Transition to Villanova. Although a lot of your essay may feature the you of high school, remember that Villanova wants to know how you might use the lesson you’ve learned to contribute to its student body. This student does an excellent job of quickly tying the “small actions, big consequences” lesson to his interest in clubs at Villanova, like TedX and the Feminist Society. Make sure to include at least 2-3 sentences about Villanova-specific resources toward the end of your essay.

  4. Circle back to the catalyzing moment or action. You don’t want your reader to forget what lesson you learned, even if this essay is really more about the “so what.” The lesson is the common thread that structures your answer. It serves as an organizational tool to connect disparate communities you’re part of. Because of that, you want to briefly bring it up again in the conclusion of your essay. In this case, the author does this by circling back to the pole-walking incident and using it as an analogy for the impact he hopes to have as a student at Villanova. You don’t have to do exactly the same thing as he does, but you should be thinking about how you can reaffirm the relevance of the lesson you learned at the end of your piece.

Option 4: At Villanova, we often say “each of us strengthens all of us.” In a time of personal challenges, how do you borrow from the strength of others?

First things first for responding to this prompt: define your challenge: Given that you only have 250 words, you might want to focus on a specific, representative challenge as opposed to several challenges. Maybe you begin by outlining a specific challenge or adversity you faced. Whether it’s academic, personal, emotional, or physical, the clearer you are about the challenge, the better readers will understand the context. It doesn't have to be a dramatic life-altering event; we’ve seen strong challenge-based essays about everything from smartphones to being pooped on.

Once you’ve identified a challenge, identify the “others”. I.e., who are the folks you’ve borrowed strength from? Maybe it was a teacher who believed in you, a friend who lent an ear when you needed it, or a family member whose resilience inspired you. It could even be a group or community you're a part of. By highlighting these individuals or groups, you're showcasing not just their impact on your life, but also your ability to recognize and appreciate the strengths in others.

Finally, reflect on the mutual exchange, as strength is often a two-way street. While you drew strength from others, in what ways did you give back or plan to? How did your experiences, bolstered by the strengths of others, shape how you interact with your community or peers? Reflecting on this reciprocal nature of strength can provide a powerful ending to your response and aligns perfectly with the essence of Villanova's statement, "each of us strengthens all of us."

Because this is a new essay prompt, we don’t have an example written specifically for it, but the example below can illustrate the direction to head in.

Example:

Camp Tecumseh is an all-boys sports sleepaway camp on the shores of Lake Winnipesaukee in New Hampshire where no camper is allowed to use their phone or any type of electronic device. This allowed us to bond more with each other and explore activities out of our comfort zones. 

I played in the annual Pemi Day, in which we would compete against our rivals from Camp Pemigewassett in soccer, tennis, swimming, and baseball. As captain of our soccer team, I was proud to help lead our comeback win after going down by two goals. Being a part of that team was one of my favorite camp memories because we remained positive throughout the whole match and never gave up.

After being encouraged by my counselor Zach and some friends, I joined them in the annual Gilbert and Sullivan Operetta. Since there weren’t any female campers, my friends and I dressed up as women, wearing dresses and makeup, and sang the soprano and alto parts. I learned that doing things outside my comfort zone is best when I do it with friends because we can support each other with these kinds of challenges. 

My time at Camp Tecumseh has led me to be more outgoing and to step out of my comfort zone.  The friends that I have made there encouraged and supported me throughout everything I did. I hope to continue to have new experiences while meeting new people who encourage and support me while I provide the same for them. (251 words)

— — —

Tips + Analysis

  1. Contrasting experiences to show growth. By juxtaposing two very different activities—the Pemi Day sports event and the Gilbert and Sullivan Operetta—the writer effectively underscores their versatility and willingness to embrace varied experiences. The soccer match is a tale of perseverance, teamwork, and leadership, familiar terrains for many, but then the narrative takes an unexpected turn. The Operetta, by contrast, gives us a peek into the writer's ability to step outside traditional boundaries, have fun, and challenge gender norms, all while emphasizing the support of friends.

  2. No phones, no problem. Starting the essay by highlighting the no-phone policy at Camp Tecumseh is pretty clever. It paints a picture of an old-school, back-to-basics experience that’s increasingly rare these days. The author could have specified any “rule” of the camp (i.e., Camp Tecumseh probably also has a policy on bringing pets), but they’re intentional about showing us the details that demonstrate that this is a place where real connections happen.

  3. Lean on me, camp edition. Through anecdotes, the writer vividly illustrates how their friends at camp were their pillars of strength, pushing them to try new things and face challenges head-on. Though this essay was written for a UMichigan prompt, it does align harmoniously with Villanova's ethos of leaning on the collective spirit to overcome personal obstacles. The result is that the writer successfully “shows” rather than “tells” how they’ve drawn strength from the community of Camp Tecumseh.

how to write Villanova Supplemental Essay Prompt #2

Why do you want to call Villanova your new home and become part of our community? Please respond in about 150 words.

This is Villanova’s version of the “Why us?” essay, with an emphasis on the Villanova community. Before you start writing, we recommend checking out this complete guide on how to write the “Why us?” essay. Pay close attention to the “Why Cornell” and “Why Penn” examples, which are our favorites, and because this is a pretty short “Why us?” prompt, check out the “Why Tufts” example. As you research Why Villanova specifics, think about options that allow you to talk about how you'll add to its community—in other words, how you’ll use your experiences/skills/talents to enhance the fabric of the Villanova campus.

As you write, try to avoid these common mistakes: 

Mistake #1: Writing about the school's size, location, reputation, weather, or ranking.

Mistake #2: Simply using emotional language to demonstrate fit.

Mistake #3: Screwing up the mascot, stadium, team colors or names of any important people or places on campus.

Mistake #4: Parroting the brochures or website language.

Mistake #5: Describing traditions the school is well-known for.

Mistake #6: Thinking of this as only a "Why them" essay.

Here’s a great example of how you can answer this prompt:

Example:

I have always wanted to expand my knowledge of animals past avians and domestic pets, and explore entomology, a subject that I have yet to discover. I wish to research different kinds of insects at The Iyengar Lab, specifically arthropods near Villanova, where I can contribute to the community by researching more about local wildlife. Additionally, I want to meet poets and fiction writers in spring during the Villanova Literary Festival and learn about their unique writing styles. Through the RUIBAL Challenge, I can inspire young, underserved students in Philadelphia to discover their interests and find joy in learning. (99 words)

— — —

Tips + Analysis:

  1. Get to the point—fast. With just 150 words on the countdown timer, now is not the time for flowery phrases and subtleties. Jump right into your essay—much like what Villanova hopes you’ll do on campus—and share how you’ll contribute. In just four direct, to-the-point sentences, we learn so much about this student: a fascination with living creatures, a love for the written word, and a dedication to serving the community. 

  2. Show some diversity. It might be tempting to spend your whole essay exploring one aspect of Villanova that makes it the must-attend university for you. But we wouldn’t recommend it. Why? You (should) know from your research that Villanova is focused on community and knowing how its students are working together for the greater good. So share how you’ll contribute to different parts of the Villanova community, in and out of the classroom. The student above does just that, covering their contributions to the lab, the campus, and the Philadelphia community.

  3. Take as much as you give. As you’re considering why you want to call Villanova home for the next four years, don’t just think about what you’re going to give. Also consider what you’re going to get. Good relationships are balanced, and your relationship with your college is no different. So while tip #2 addresses what you’re bringing to Villanova, you also want to demonstrate that the Nova Nation is going to fit your needs, too. What opportunities does it offer that dovetails perfectly with your interests? If your curiosity is piqued by insects (and why there are so darn many), like this student’s is, then it’s clear a school with an entire lab devoted to researching the sexual selection of insects is the right place for you.

Special thanks to Nick Muccio for writing this blog post.

Rather than candy, Nick (he/him) went searching for people’s vacuum cleaners when trick or treating. He’s since found other ways to help people clean, usually involving their essays (though he has great ideas on carpet maintenance, too). He earned a degree in Psychology from Bates College, where he rowed boats and acted in plays. Teaching high schoolers English for seven years taught him about the importance of presence and knitting sweaters. He sweats a lot, usually on purpose, and usually involving running shoes, a bike, or a rock climbing harness. His greatest fear? Heights. His greatest joys? Numerous, though shared laughter is up there.