Last Updated on 10/08/2026 by Ethan Sawyer
Every year, some version of this question lands in our inbox: “Nothing bad has ever really happened to me. What am I supposed to write about?”
The short answer: Your life. The things that fill it and make it yours and have shaped your values and sense of self.
Those don’t have to be dramatic or traumatic things. For most people, they won’t be. That’s fine.
A good college essay topic is anything that helps an admissions reader understand the skills, qualities, values, and interests you’ll bring to their campus. That’s the whole job. And sure, a dramatic experience can do that, but it’s just one route among many. It’s not required. And it’s often not the easiest one. (We wrote a whole post on why you don’t have to write about trauma to stand out, if you want the longer version.)
So if you haven’t faced a big challenge, you’re not behind. You probably just need a different structure. Which we’ll talk through below.
Why “no big challenge” is no big problem
Students, at least some, tend to assume admissions officers want hardship. But what they want is to see you, and one dramatic experience doesn’t show them that any better (or sometimes at all) than other approaches can.
An essay about a car accident can easily end up being about the car accident.
If you’ve had a fairly steady life, you’ve still got something else going for you: lots of small moments that each show a different side of who you are. That’s raw material for what we call a montage essay.
What Montage Structure is (and why it works for “ordinary” lives)
A montage is a series of moments that may seem unrelated at first but come together through a unifying theme. You know them, even if you don’t know you know. Think of a film montage: a few quick scenes (usually without dialogue), and by the end you understand something about the character that no single scene could’ve told you.
In a montage essay, the unifying theme (we tend to call it a “thread” or “focusing lens”) connects several different sides of yourself. Each paragraph shows a new value, skill, quality, and/or interest, and the thread keeps it from feeling like a random list of experiences.
You don’t need one huge story. You can do just as much (often more, actually) with four or five small, true ones and a smart way to connect them.
(For the full walkthrough, see our free guide to montage structure. Want to compare it to the other main approach? Here’s narrative structure.)
Good college essay topics that work as a Montage thread
A good thread is something you know well and that can plausibly connect to several parts of your life. Some examples:
- A hobby with range. One of our favorite example essays uses escape rooms as its thread. Through escape rooms, the writer shows analytical thinking, community leadership, intellectual curiosity, creativity, and resilience after setbacks. As that guide puts it, colleges care less about the topic and more about you.
- A recurring image. The “Umbra” essay in our personal statement examples uses light to connect performing, robotics, research, and family traditions.
- An object you own. Your laptop stickers, a worn-out pair of cleats, a spice drawer, a playlist. (Our Essence Objects exercise is built to help you find these.)
- A skill or “superpower.” Fixing things, making strangers comfortable, remembering everyone’s birthday.
- A role you play. The friend people call at midnight, the family translator, the person who always ends up planning the trip.
Notice none of these are dramatic. They’re specific. And that specificity is what makes them work.
How to build a Montage essay in four steps
1. Start with values, not topics
Before you pick a thread, figure out what you’d want a reader to know about you. Our Values Exercise takes about five minutes, and the top few values you land on become the “points” your essay makes.
2. List moments that show each value
For each value, jot down two or three moments from your life that show it in action. Small is fine (Small can even be better). Just show us. Moments of you reorganizing your family’s garage so dad could find his tools can say more about something like resourcefulness than “I am a resourceful person” ever will.
3. Find the thread that connects them
Look at your list and ask: What do these moments have in common? Maybe they all happened in the kitchen. Maybe they involve maps, or music, or your younger brother. If nothing jumps out, that’s fine—start with an object or activity and ask what else in your life it connects to.
4. Go deeper in each paragraph
The common trap here? A résumé in paragraph form. The fix: show each moment briefly, then reflect on what it taught you or how it’s changed the way you see things. Insight is what turns a list of activities into an essay.
(If your draft still feels flat, try these two fixes for a boring college essay.)
A quick gut check before you commit to a topic
Ask yourself: Could someone else write this exact essay? If yes, get more specific. Many, many people play soccer. Not everybody keeps a notebook of every ref’s call they disagreed with and what it taught them about their ability to see fairness when they zoom out far enough.
Then ask: Does each paragraph show something new about me? If two paragraphs make the same point, cut one and find a moment that shows a different side of you.
Where to go from here
Try the Values Exercise tonight, then ten minutes of Essence Objects. You’ll probably end up with more material than 650 words can hold. Which is a nice problem to have.
For more ideas, see 21 college essay topics that worked or our guide to what to write your college essay about.
Take care, and have fun with it.
Andrew Simpson, CEG’s Editorial Director, has worked as an educator, consultant, and curriculum writer for the past 20 years, and earned degrees from Stanford in Political Science and Drama. He feels most at home on mountain tops and in oceans.
Top Values: Insight/Growth | Truth | Integrity
